My Little Pony Dolls
AVERAGE OG PRICE: $13 (new)
MIGHT FLIP FOR: $900 (vintage)
Can you believe that 150 million My Little Pony toys were sold in the U.S. in the 1980s? The babies shook the toy market for sure. Introduced in 1982, the franchise featuring magical, colorful ponies captures the hearts and minds of fans even today. New versions of the pony are still being created to this day.
However, it’s the vintage ones that rake in the most cash. The ones with highest quality hair and clear markings or symbols can be sold for lots. However, it’s the mail-order ponies that were ordered with “pony points,” and the “flutter ponies” (ones with wings) that are worth the most according to GOBankingRates. Probably because your kid today will not appreciate the significance of these ponies, you better make the most of it by putting it up for sale.